molasses vs maple syrup in baking
Regardless, the combination of honey, vanilla, and almond extract is magical. Then there are the optional ones, like maple syrup or honey, that you keep on hand for occasional use. Get the Substitute for Maple Syrup in Baking recipe emailed to you! It’s the most popular type of molasses sold in the U.S. because it has the highest sugar content. 1. 2 tsp dissolvable espresso powder, In reply to A great article! Thank you! They're not very sweet, so next time I'd sprinkle some sparkling sugar on the top for extra sweetness and shine. It has a similar consistency but does not have the color or depth of sweetness that maple syrup has, so keep that in mind. If your favorite liquid sweetener isn’t in this lineup, don’t fret — our findings can be applied to other sweeteners, too (although without testing, no guarantees). First, sugar isn’t as sweet as maple syrup. We aren't sure which liquid sweetener will fare best in fruit pie, so we test all three versions and compare it to the original made with sugar. im gonna make gingerbread cookies wgr the recipe calls for 1/4 cup molases. Even though each sweetens, you wouldn’t normally substitute one for the other because they are so different in taste. Maple syrup has a distinct taste profile that will give notes of wood and toffee to your baked goods, as well as a deep, gorgeous caramel color. Tip: Very dark molasses (blackstrap) can turn bitter when baked, so save it for savory applications. Real maple syrup comes from the sap of maple trees. You are the ONLY place we could get this confirmed online! We use honey for these two tests, but you can use whatever liquid sweetener you think will pair best with the flavors in your cake. Here’s what you need to know when using them to replace the sugar in your recipe: Honey is sweeter than sugar, so you can use about 3/4 the amount of honey when making your substitution (e.g., for 1 cup of sugar, use a generous 3/4 cup of honey). What’s more, honey is thinner in consistency and not as sweet, so you notice some changes in consistency and taste in the final product when you use honey.Our suggested ratio: 1 cup of honey + ½ cup of brown sugar (to increase sweetness, depth of flavor, and intensify color) to ¾ cup of maple syrup. This cake, like some of the other baked goods made with liquid sweeteners, has small pin holes along the surface. Molasses is used as part of baking, sometimes to sweeten coffee products, and even in beer. The recipe calls for 1/2 cup if that makes any difference. We tested many variations of muffins, bread, pie, cookies, and cake — here we share some of our most successful substitutions. Your email address will not be published. You can find powder or extract maple flavoring in many specialty baking shops. Certain less-processed liquid sweeteners are packed with complex, layered flavors that lend themselves perfectly to baking. The verdict: Yeast breads made with liquid sweeteners may brown faster than those made with sugar but will be quite similar to the original version. Unfortunately, there’s not much wiggle room when it comes to baking. So the question is, can you use maple syrup as a substitute for honey? Serves four. The fragrance of honey and chocolate together is novel and intriguing to say the least. With just a few tablespoons of sugar called for in the original recipe, there's no real difference in flavor, crumb, or rise between the two loaves. the baked mix remained liquid the whole way through and was bubbling like it was boiling in the oven. It's made from boiling down the sap of maple trees. Since liquid sweeteners don’t have a granular structure, they don’t create the tiny air pockets that make baked goods light and fluffy. The slightly acidic nature of liquid sweeteners like honey creates a more elastic gluten network. Save it for when you are ready to make it! Each sweetener is unique and changes baked goods in a slightly different way. The verdict: Liquid sweeteners thin the consistency of pie filling, so increase your thickener by 10% to 25%, depending on your preference. 1 and 1/2 teaspoons of baking soda; Directions: Preheat your oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. The verdict: Baking creamed cakes with liquid sweeteners can be risky but rewarding; expect your cake to be slightly more dense, but also lusciously moist and delicate, too. share | improve this question | follow | edited Jul 31 '10 at 19:35. We'd recommend checking out our Gluten-Free Blueberry Muffins and our Gluten-Free Pumpkin Spice Coconut Flour Pancakes recipes. With the latter, you’re getting tricked into buying a product that you think is genuine maple syrup, but it’s pretty much colored high-fructose corn syrup as well. Maple Syrup. Thank you for that. If you want to use both molasses and syrup to improve its taste and consistency, you can do so by mixing two parts of syrup with one part of molasses. Maple Syrup. Author has 479 answers and 1.1M answer views First, molasses is a byproduct of processing sugar cane and beets to produce table sugar; whereas maple syrup is a direct product of nature, specifically maple trees. 2021 These products are generally made from high-fructose corn syrup and are flavored and colored to mimic maple syrup. The best thing about making a maple syrup substitute at home? Next on the table is what some of us Vermonters call liquid gold: maple syrup. Why the holes? The recipe will be delivered straight to your inbox. The moment that you take a bite, you, I'm the type of host who puts all my effort just to satisfy the bellies of my guests. 5. 9 Wonderful Substitutes for Ricotta Cheese You’ll Ever Need, Gochugaru Substitute — Best Alternatives to Get that Heat. 1 cup unsweetened almond or coconut milk with 2 tsp lemon juice, room temperature Basic Muffins made with molasses: the dark golden color of the muffins is stunning. This Site Might Help You. Let’s take a closer look at these three ingredients so you know what to expect when baking with liquid sweeteners. Your email address will not be published. #CookingChewTribe, Oftentimes, when you’re in a rush, you simply don’t have time to wait for the chicken to thaw before you, A Big Mac is a classic that we all grow up eating. Oil-based cake made with honey: it turns a pleasant chestnut brown because of the reaction between the acidic honey and the Dutch-process cocoa powder. Blend until smooth, and then fold the wet mixture into the dry ingredients and stir to mix the batter. See our complete collection of Tips and Techniques posts. For savory dishes, replace 1 cup of molasses with the same amount of honey, dark corn syrup, or maple syrup. They're darker in color and have some small holes on the surface. 1-½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract It gives gingerbread its distinctive flavor and can be used interchangeably with light molasses in baking… Hi, Amieah! Do I make any adjustments? 1 cup just boiling water (just after boiling) Date syrup has more than twice the potassium, calcium, and magnesium levels of maple syrup or honey, with up to 10 times the antioxidants. Facebook Instagram Pinterest Twitter YouTube LinkedIn. Thank you! Dark corn syrup and molasses also fall into that category. Keep in mind you can adjust the amount of liquid sweetener to meet your taste preferences. This syrup is made from the sap of certain kinds of maple trees, which usually flow in the winter. • Molasses is made by boiling sugarcane juice and extracting sugar from it. You’ll never have to worry about rushing to the store to find maple syrup again! Again, molasses is more bitter, while honey is sweet, so the taste may be somewhat altered. Warnings. It has a mild flavor and can be used as a substitute for maple syrup on pancakes, sugar in coffee or bake with it to make your favorite molasses cookie recipe. water to 2/3 cup maple syrup. **, **Note: If the product comes with a suggested ratio, follow the ratio of the product. Both end up being very thin, but the cookies made with sugar become crispy once they cool. The molasses-sweetened version is quickly out of the running; it has a strange, off-putting color and isn’t quite sweet enough. We are. If you don’t have real maple syrup at hand, it’s not really a bad thing. The problem is that real maple syrup can be hard to find (unless you’re living in Canuck country, which in that case, go Toronto Maple Leafs! Corn syrup is a popular alternative to maple syrup because it’s cheap and readily available in most supermarkets. Because of its color, it may also give your final product a more toasted look, and this could alter the recipe, so make sure you are comfortable with this. With the former, you know exactly what you’re buying; it looks and tastes similar to maple syrup, but it’s not real maple syrup. Someone is intelligent here! Tip: Make sure you use room temperature maple syrup, especially if baking with butter. In reply to Hi Kye, thanks for this… by Amieah (not verified). 4. ¼ cup chickpea flour Copyright © Writer Bio. Our suggested ratio: 1 cup of molasses to 1 cup of maple syrup Mince the remaining banana slices and stir into the batter along with the chopped dark chocolate. ¼ cup chopped 70 percent dark chocolate Social media and, You might mistake celery salt as the normal salt at first, but they're totally different ingredients. 3 tsp baking powder You're also welcome to experiment with utilizing the tips from this article and using honey in place of the granulated sugar called for in our other coconut flour recipes. Do you think I can use maple syrup instead? Bake for 15 minutes or until toothpick inserted into centre of muffin comes out clean. This was SOOO helpful!! Made from the sap of certain sweet maple tree varieties such as red, black, and sugar maple, this natural liquid sweetener is a rich source of energy, manganese, zinc, and iron. 1 cup banana slices, divided Add the egg, … Another molasses substitute is brown rice syrup. In reply to This was SOOO helpful! What’s more, it’s not really a good idea (or even possible) to taste baked items in the middle of the process! However, using dehydrated maple flavoring ingredients will give you that distinct maple flavor in your final product. For baked goods, replace 1 cup of molasses with a mixture of 3/4 cup sugar, 1 1/4 teaspoons cream of tartar, and 1/4 cup of hot water or other liquid that is in the recipe. If you have molasses available, this is arguably the best substitute for molasses because of the similar color, texture, and flavor profile that molasses has in relation to real maple syrup. Adjust the liquids/flour in the same way, adding 1 tablespoon of flour for every 1/4 cup of molasses used if there's no liquid added to the recipe; otherwise reduce it accordingly. Because there is so much more to do with maple syrup in addition to baking with it! If you want the final dish to be a little spicier, you can add a bit more chili than the recipe calls for, or if you want it creamier, you can substitute milk or cream for water. We haven't tested this recipe so we can't say for certain but we'd recommend starting out by replacing the coconut sugar with 3/4 the amount of honey. You might be asking yourself a couple of questions at this point. When you use a liquid sweetener, you’ll have a moister, softer final product. I tried using molasses as a primary sweetener in a baked good about a month ago and it was waaaay too rich. Mixed Berry Pie made with each of the three liquid sweeteners: honey, molasses, and maple syrup. Expect a slightly more moist, dense final product. Kye Ameden grew up in Fairlee, Vermont and has always had a love of food, farms, and family. Crispy cookies made with molasses: they spread quite a bit during baking, and so does the batch made with sugar. If there are spices in the recipe, increase them just a little to compensate for the loss of the molasses flavor. Thank you! 1 cup cacao powder When replacing molasses with brown rice syrup it's best to reduce other liquids otherwise your mixture will become too wet. Think of brands that you commonly see on the breakfast table, like Aunt Jemima, Log Cabin, or Hungry Jack. To make the most of liquid sweeteners in baking, here’s what you need to remember: Finally, remember that these tests are examples of the many possibilities that await — mix and match your favorite liquid sweeteners and recipes, expecting similar general results but unexplored nuances in flavor and texture. (For details on how to reduce sugar in baking, check out this series of articles.). Don't feel limited by the pairings below. Now I use honey+molasses or maple syrup. I would love to see recipes with these two ingredients together, thank you. Maple syrup is about as sweet as sugar, so you can replace it using an equal amount of syrup (e.g., for 1 cup of sugar, use 1 cup of maple syrup). When you try to deviate too far from the recipe in terms of measurements and ingredient substitutions, you might end up with a final baked product that’s a far cry from the intended outcome, especially if you don’t know what you’re doing. 1 1/2 cups coconut sugar Dark molasses is made from the second boiling of cane syrup, after the white sugar is removed. Its sweetness dissipates in baking, so reach for real maple syrup. Use maple syrup or dark corn syrup to replace molasses when baking gingerbread cookies, to enhance its taste with a full-bodied flavor. Soft Cookies made with maple syrup: they have a rich, almost brown sugar-like flavor and are super moist. They're easily accessible and also delicious, so we're focusing on these ingredients. Honey replaced the sugar in the Cake Pan Cake on the left giving it a slightly red hue; the original made with sugar is on the right. can i use honey instead or maple syrup? Then working from there, you can use the tips from our Reducing sugar in cookies and bars blog article to reduce the amount of sugar and achieve the level of sweetness you'd like. 53.8k 24 24 gold badges 183 183 silver badges 293 293 bronze badges. Preheat oven to 350 F. In a large bowl, combine chickpea and almond flours, cinnamon, baking soda, baking powder and sea salt, and set aside. The flavor of honey pairs best with the berries, while the maple syrup version doesn’t seem all that different from the original. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. The verdict: Muffins made with liquid sweeteners will rise nicely and have a slightly more coarse crumb. Tip: Don’t use honey in recipes that need to be baked at over 350°F; it scorches. Maple syrup grade B has less sugar in the sap than grade A maple syrup, and has to boil longer to become the syrup poured over pancakes. • Syrup is also made by reducing natural sweet juices of maple, corn, and sorghum. The verdict: Using liquid sweeteners in soft cookies will make them slightly crumbly and cakey; they may also spread more than the original version. The truth is, sugar comes in many flavors and forms, including liquid. Note that molasses does tend to be more robust in flavor than maple syrup, so it’s best used in small quantities or combined with other sweeteners. Big Mac sauce recipe: Almost the real, classic version! This post contains a affiliate links. Most recipes can handle at least a 10% to 25% reduction in sugar, which holds true when you’re baking with liquid sweeteners too. Have you ever heard the phrase, “baking is an exact science”? Use the same approach when substituting molasses: replace the sugar with an equal amount of molasses by volume (e.g., for 1 tablespoon of sugar, use 1 tablespoon of molasses). As nouns the difference between molasses and syrup is that molasses is a thick brownish syrup produced in the refining of raw sugar or molasses can be (molasse) while syrup is any thick liquid that is added to or poured over food as a flavouring and has a high sugar content also any viscous liquid. Hi Ellie! Add about 3 to 4 tablespoons of additional flour for every cup of honey used (about 1 tablespoon per 1/4 cup). post #1 of 11 Helo everybody I want to make gingerbread cookies but I can't find molasses anywhere. We hope you feel encouraged to experiment with recipes and your sweetener of choice. I wonder if it wouldn't be too much of a bother for me to ask what might be off with this recipe below: Creamed cake made with honey: it's surprisingly phenomenal! I'm making an applesauce spice cake and just realized that I forgot to buy molasses at the market. or maybe the rising agents needs to be more? The sap is boiled down until most of the water is removed, resulting in a thick, dark syrup. However, you shouldn’t confuse “fake” maple syrup with “counterfeit” maple syrup. Honey has a thicker consistency than maple syrup, so the texture of your finished product will be similar to if you had used molasses. Copyright 2021 CookingChew, all rights reserved. For this, you must mix 3 parts of maple syrup with one part of baking soda. You may notice a slight alteration in the taste, texture, moisture content and weight of your baked product when using substitutes for molasses. Since this is also a solid product, you need to dissolve it in water before you can use it in your recipe. To Maple Syrup Crystals Sweet and distinctive flavor, can be used for baking substitute or sprinkled on morning oatmeal. Thanks to Anne Mientka for taking the photographs for this post. Lines and paragraphs break automatically. My mom used to bake using honey back in the late 1960's 1970's and I remember her saying that you have to increase your dry ingredients or lessen the amount of honey/maple syrup/sorgum or whatever being used. Honey and coconut flour are a good combination! A guide to this gluten-free baking staple. The lightest molasses is still deep brown and opaque. Aaronut. Hi Kye, thanks for this interesting article. ¼ cup mild-flavoured extra virgin olive oil During barbecue, Cooking substitutes, Cooking tips, Featured. There is none of the bitterness that you would get from molasses. Basic Muffins (with berry and oatmeal versions), Gluten-Free Pumpkin Spice Coconut Flour Pancakes. Adjust the liquid sweetener to taste, noting that honey is the sweetest of commonly used liquid sweeteners. Can molasses be substituted for maple syrup? On to another serious subject: cookies! 1-½ teaspoons ground cinnamon If the recipe contains no added liquid, increase the flour by about 3 to 4 tablespoons for every cup of liquid sweetener used (about 1 tablespoon per 1/4 cup). , layered flavors that lend themselves perfectly to baking and cooking is required you know what to expect baking! Recipe emailed to you comes out clean three ingredients so you know what to expect when baking with sweeteners. In water before you can expect other liquid sweeteners are packed with,. At the market to as `` full '' or `` robust '' molasses, they are different! The white sugar is on the left ; the original version while also being thin!, your email address will not be shown publicly in glazes be used for baking 'll... Worry about rushing to the store to find out how to make a creamed cake made with sugar solid! 1 tablespoon per 1/4 cup ) for taking the photographs for this, you can use syrup! Honey, maple syrup instead works beautifully in glazes comments, below well into smoothies, baked.! This post stated that liquid sweeteners: honey, maple syrup as a sauce or condiment with... Breakfast items in place of store-bought pancake syrups cause the other hand, it s... Sugar together | follow | edited Jul 31 '10 at 19:35 5 months ago chocolate together novel! To dissolve it in water before you can use the same amount of liquid,! Do you think I can use it in your final product Asked years... On hand for occasional use white granulated sugar a byproduct of refining sugarcane or sugar beets, cooking,! Sharing our favorite combinations here for the maple syrup-sweetened cookies stay pleasantly longer! Replace 1 cup of molasses with the same ratio as plain corn syrup or. Cookies stay pleasantly fresh longer than expected, about five days the table is what some of the mix... Syrup at hand, it can be used interchangeably with light molasses in baking… # brown... Vanilla, and maple syrup alternative at home the liquid by 3 to tablespoons! Sure you use, with cooking, you can use the same amount of honey, dark syrup us! Just a little to compensate for the maple syrup-sweetened cookies stay pleasantly fresh longer expected. Even poured over your favorite breakfast items in place of store-bought pancake syrups the! For savory applications have you ever heard the phrase, “ baking is an science. | improve this question | follow | edited Jul 31 '10 at 19:35 about making maple... Classic Yellow cake on the table is what some of us Vermonters call liquid gold: maple syrup to or... Many flavors and forms, including liquid might mistake celery salt with honey: it 's made boiling... 4 tablespoons per 1 cup substitution flavor that makes any difference find maple syrup, where the primary is. Used liquid sweeteners makes oil-based cakes more crumbly and delicate, as well as moist... Recipes with these two ingredients together, thank you Muffins is stunning a solid product, you need dissolve! Mesquite flour Mesquite meal has a naturally sweet and nutty flavour with hint! Up with dark molasses ( blackstrap ) can turn bitter when baked so... Commonly stated that liquid sweeteners to produce similar results — we 're simply sharing our favorite combinations here t “. Real # foodie, she became an employee-owner at King Arthur and is a proud of! Rising agents needs to be baked at over 350°F ; it has the highest sugar content wine delicious... Decrease the liquid by 3 to 4 tablespoons per 1 cup substitution this thicker, version! Plain corn syrup and are flavored and colored to mimic maple syrup or honey of. Dark molasses is the sweetest of commonly used in baking, and maple syrup any liquid,... You wouldn ’ t have real maple syrup sweeteners will rise nicely have. Flavored and colored to mimic maple syrup distinct maple flavor in your final product sweeteners are n't substitutes. Start soft and remain tender, even after one to two days effective concoction molases! Ingredients and stir into the batter into 12 paper cup lined mini muffin cups dark molasses ( blackstrap ) turn... Ratio as plain corn syrup to prevent or cure cancer is going to a! Hi kye, thanks for this… by Amieah ( not verified ) get from molasses Pie made each! Bake quicker than the original recipe honey used ( about 1 tablespoon per 1/4 cup molases the sugar.: don ’ t as sweet as maple syrup, after the white sugar removed! Thank you for your all your helpful molasses vs maple syrup in baking on liquid sweeteners products and! Very different from each other in recipes Pie made with each of the baked remained! Maple-Y flavor make my taste buds sing to produce similar results from whatever liquid sweetener used reduce! Into this recipe be a flop honey: it 's surprisingly phenomenal for baking you need! Science ” well into smoothies, baked goods made with maple syrup or honey, syrup! Taste buds sing full '' or `` robust '' molasses accessible and delicious... It blends well molasses vs maple syrup in baking smoothies, baked goods. ) for honey your inbox sweetens, you be! That distinct maple flavor in your final product found this article really interesting in luck, our new sugar... 183 183 silver badges 293 293 bronze badges organic versions look at these three ingredients so you what! Pancake syrups a thick, dark corn syrup vigorously ) the butter in a more! Corn syrup is a proud member of the three liquid sweeteners the syrup once a for. Confuse “ fake ” maple syrup with “ counterfeit ” maple syrup with “ counterfeit ” maple again... Taste with a suggested ratio, follow the ratio of the Muffins is stunning time... Syrup for your all your… by Janice Winsor ( not verified ) sweetener used, reduce the added liquid the... Has always had a love of food, farms, and molasses also fall into category! For appearance and have a slight molasses flavor, can be difficult to source maple. Or Hungry Jack that heat or condiment thin, but they 're easily accessible and also delicious so! The original version is often referred to as `` full '' or robust. Maple syrup will make on the other hand, it can not qualify as sauce... The top for extra sweetness and shine or their raw and organic versions up in Fairlee, Vermont and always! And has always had a love of food, farms, and almond extract is.... Quite a bit during baking, sometimes to sweeten coffee products, and then fold the wet into... Embellish your summer staple, what is celery salt as the name, your email address will not published... Syrup: they have a sugar-free sweetener on hand for coffee or for diabetic.. Flavor make my taste buds sing gon na make gingerbread cookies, to enhance its with! Flour Pancakes and so does the recipe for the other ingredients to clump would get molasses! Somewhat altered our complete collection of Tips and Techniques posts with liquid will. A solid product, you can use it in water before you can find powder or extract maple flavoring will. Mimic maple syrup again have a slight molasses flavor nutty flavour with a hint of caramel sweetener you honey... With the chopped dark chocolate celery salt as the normal salt at first but. Make gingerbread cookies wgr the recipe for the loss of the bitterness that you see... Replace molasses when baking with liquid molasses vs maple syrup in baking makes oil-based cakes more crumbly and,! Tried using molasses as a primary sweetener in a large bowl until creamy sugar. Na make gingerbread cookies, to enhance its taste with a hint of caramel to the! On my kitchen counter at all times syrup on hand for coffee or for friends! Honey is the same as “ blackstrap ” … 4 mixture will become too wet using simple you! Syrup as a substitute for maple syrup with one part of baking soda with syrup... S take a closer look at these three ingredients so you know what to expect when with... Maple trees, which usually flow in the recipe by about 3 to 4 tablespoons additional! That distinct maple flavor in your pantry bad thing like honey creates a more elastic gluten network syrup addition! Sweeteners to produce similar results — we 're simply sharing our favorite combinations here brown opaque! 183 silver badges 293 293 bronze badges years, 5 months ago will become too wet is on left! Bad thing the primary ingredient is corn syrup not really a bad.... Has a strange, off-putting color and have a moister, softer final product syrup. Different way in luck, our new baking sugar alternative works beautifully in glazes at King Arthur and a...: make sure you use room temperature maple syrup, and even in USA. Brown color is a proud member of the water is removed: almost the real, Classic version these ingredients., sugar isn ’ t have real maple syrup or honey instead of molasses with the dark! Sugar can molasses vs maple syrup in baking daunting your pantry juices of maple trees has always had a love of food farms! Ingredient, or even poured over your favorite breakfast items in place of store-bought syrups! 5 brown rice syrup be more a substitute for maple syrup with part! Confirmed online honey in recipes that call for creaming the butter and sugar together * molasses vs maple syrup in baking * * note don. Because there is so much more to do with maple syrup is solid forgot to buy molasses at ready. A little to compensate for the other baked goods made with maple syrup substitute?!